Budget 2009 – What matters most

With no changes in tax rates but higher spending toward social sector projects, Minister for External Affairs Pranab Mukherjee Monday tabled a Rs.952,231 crore (Rs.9.52 trillion/$190.6 billion) interim budget for 2009-10 that chose to give fiscal prudence a miss during “extraordinary economic circumstances”. MSN

This is an interim budget and a vote of account, a political speech, an attempt to gain free airtime to woo the voters and promote the party in the next general election

What matters most i think is the broader policy direction or the bigger picture  the Party in Power and its allys ie Congress and the UPA are hinting of taking this nation and it doesnt look quite so good.

The markets just gave their verdict! A big Thumbs down! Poof  Rs 1 trillion vanished on Budget day.

The last year saw an unprecedented boom in the markets worldwide, lots of new indirect taxes, a beaming fm, confident of double digit gdp growth rate, record breaking tax collections and fii investment, a bubble in the commodities, property and stock markets  and massive spending by the govt, in terms of doles, loan waivers and off budget items like subsidy and oil bonds . The Yuvraj spoke…

Wonder why he  talked about the failure of our family planning program, during the nukular (nuclear) debate… what do u think  ?

Laloo the Rail Minister of Bihar entertained us with wonderful english during the rail budget..

As the calendars changed the big boom went bust Satyam pulled a Maytas and the Andra Govt attempted a coverup and all the dreams came a crashing. People commented that this is the worst recession comparable in some aspects to the Great Depression of 30s.

We also saw little or no reform  governance or liberalization, a tug of war, a vote of no confidence with its customary bundles of cash and change of alliance  from the Communists to the Samajwadis,  most appreciated by the okkur pardesh Cm and the bade bahi of bollywood(whose tax problems vanished in thin air)…

I dont need to remind u of the regular terror attacks …

The policy approach and statements by the matriarch of Congress reminded us of the emergency and its declarer, as reforms took a back seat and the Oil Psus bled, the Psu Banks got diktats, to populist measures  like the infamous loan waivers and gas shortages and general price rise in daily essentials. There is no strong impetus on education or  infrastructure and Nregs is not doing anything to build permanent infrastructure…The NHDP is dead .. Read UPA fails to finish a single highway project. There is lack of accountability that too directly from the PMO.  Read PMO U-turn on RTI, won’t reveal ministers’ assets – Express India

It also saw our figure fudging, uber confident ex fm Mr Chidambaram , who was recently shifted to the home ministry, still holding on to his targets,  or behave like an ostrich as overzealous targets in terms of tax collections, gdp growth rates, frbm were revised downwards and fiscal deficit mounted . He had said FII inflows aren’t hot money, but circumstance proved him wrong as Fiis pulled out a massive amts of money to fill those massive holes in their balance sheets.

The Rupee has fluctuated wildly during the last fiscal yr, showing a devaluation of 19% against the falling dollar by yr end, the worst performance since 91, busting the myth that its all because of the international recessionary trends..z2

Credit rating agencies are not amused , and are hinting on an impending downgrade in ratings. Standard and Poor’s rates Asia’s third-biggest economy’s local currency rating at “BBB – minus”, or the lowest investment-grade level, with a stable outlook. Fitch has a similar rating but with a negative outlook while Moody’s pegs it at one notch lower at speculative grade.

The markets have crashed from the mighty highs and people who invested during the peaks have conservatively lost at least 40% of their capital in most equity investments.


Finally the Pm/FM has a unique legacy he is leaving us with. The affinity to number 10. He takes instructions from 10 janpath, he took the hot seat of the FM during desperate times when whe had a huge bop crises and deficit was over 10%, ushering in reform and liberalization, not by choice but due to desperation. He leaves us in a similar or worse off situation with the overall deficit  of well over 10%.

Difficult times still lie ahead, and the kind of spending envisaged in this vote on account does not auger well for the nation, especially if it is to be funded by excessive govt borrowing. The RBI chief, who is ex Finance ministry is dangling the OMO carrot as he is running out of options, and demand for govt debt is falling.


India’s c/a, fiscal deficit widen, outlook gloomy

India’s damaging fiscal deficit

Fiscal alarm for India

The only way out is to monetize the deficit

10 YEARS OF REFORM 1991 – 2001


6 thoughts on “Budget 2009 – What matters most

  1. i did not get time to deeply analyse the budget, but most of my friends agree the new acting FM has delivered a budget that is worse than what he had delivered last time ago (about 2 decades ago)

  2. prax
    1. try to stick to one topic, one thought in a single post. It should be ok if you split this post into 2…. one FM/Budget bashing, and second about how rahul and laloo are making a mockery of the Parliament.

    2. Although hilarious, i would give laloo a benefit of the doubt… the people whom he represent are primarily hindi speaking and Lalo’s bhojpuri is indeed impeccable… i am sure if u or i spoke a foreign language.. and worse address a public gathering in French.. we would do the same.

    3. When i saw the way u had presented the nuclear deal video, i had thought of the worst.
    a. rahul trying to link that somehow there is a nuclear solution to India’s problem (the only one that i can think involves a mushroom cloud)
    b. he is trying to talk about the initiatives that his uncle took for family planning.
    the only benefit i got by watching the video is that my convictions that Rahul is not articulate and is not fit to lead the country is reinforced.

  3. agree , but there is nothing much to talk about or analyze in this budget, as it seems to be more of a political exercise than a serious stimulus plan etc
    Thus the upa analysis because the party/s have put the nations finances in a precarious situation
    I dont know whom to vote for because the other alternatives esp the third front will be worse, and bjp is also loosing the big picture.

    I was laloo bashing not bhojpuri bashing because he i think is an incompetent administrator of the railways, and because his policy is biharcentric, and has done nothing to improve the pathetic situation of mumbai suburban passangers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s